WASHINGTON — The Merchants Payments Coalition on Monday urged a federal judge to reject a proposed settlement over Visa and Mastercard credit card swipe fees, arguing it would offer retailers only modest, temporary savings while leaving the fee-setting process largely unchanged.
U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan, who granted preliminary approval in June, held a hearing in New York to consider whether to give the agreement final approval. The coalition said more than 1,000 merchants and trade associations opposed the deal, including 978 that signed a joint objection letter two months earlier.
Cogan said he was unlikely to send the parties back to the negotiating table if he rejected the agreement. “If I reject this, it’s going to trial,” he said, according to the coalition’s account of the hearing. A trial would require about two months of preparation and another two months of proceedings, he said, with additional time needed to determine remedies if merchants prevail.
The proposal stems from a 2005 class-action lawsuit alleging that Visa and Mastercard violated federal antitrust law by centrally setting the interchange fees charged by banks issuing cards on their networks. A federal appeals court overturned an earlier settlement in 2016, and U.S. District Judge Margo Brodie rejected a later proposal in 2024.
Under the latest proposal, interchange fees would drop by one-tenth of a percentage point for five years, the coalition said. Merchants paid an average swipe fee of 2.36% in 2025, it said. The reduction would apply to fees collected by card-issuing banks, while Visa and Mastercard could still raise the separate fees they charge to operate their networks. The coalition also said the agreement would prevent merchants from bringing similar claims for at least eight years.
The deal would allow merchants to reject certain higher-cost rewards cards and cap interchange fees on standard cards at 1.25%. The coalition argued these provisions would have limited impact, since rewards cards account for more than 90% of credit card spending. It also said state laws and network rules would make it difficult for merchants to use the provision allowing surcharges of up to 3%.
Mithun Mansinghani, an attorney representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, told the court that the proposal would do little to encourage competition among card issuers. Deborah Greenberg, representing the National Retail Federation and the Retail Industry Leaders Association, urged Cogan to consider the breadth of merchant opposition when deciding whether to approve the deal.